Blogging Doesn’t Benefit From A Tentative Voice

There is an article floating around on the internet called Why Crazy People Make Better Bloggers. It is a ridiculous post; however, every person who hates this article seems to say things like, “I’m not crazy. I write interesting content. I am a great blogger.”

Cute. You wish.

Even though I disagree with the premise of article, I like the spirit. Blogging doesn’t benefit from a tentative voice. The best writers out there are brave and deliberate storytellers. They can weave lessons into the most mundane aspects of their existence. They can manipulate an audience.

And they can write.

Sure, these bloggers could be crazy. They might lead unorthodox lives. They might suffer from bouts of depression and anxiety. But who doesn’t? We know that most of America is on Lipitor because we’re chubby, Prozac because we’re depressed, and Xanax because we are edgy.

Fortunately, much of the drama you read on the internet is just for show. Just like JK Rowling created Hogwarts, these bloggers create captivating and magical worlds that will never match the mundane reality of their lives. When it comes to the most compelling content, you know that most of it is fictitious or relies heavily upon the author’s ability to stretch the truth.

You read it anyway. You enjoy reading blogs written by liars.

And I’m cool with that. The culture of micro-celebrity demands a narrative that fits too neatly into the model of creative writing MFA programs across the country. The 21st century professional writer suffers from the delusion that every main character must have a moment of self-reflection and personal realization in order to make the story complete. These bloggers try to shoehorn their lives into a living and breathing example of The Iowa Writers’ Workshop.

That’s how it’s done in 2011. But you should know that successful bloggers lead boring lives filled with Chips Ahoy, Diet Coke and too much TV. We want to believe otherwise; however, reality is truly disappointing. These writers are soccer moms with flat asses, flawed husbands, and boring dorks. They put on their glasses and mouth guards at night — just like you and me.

I am a mildly successful blogger by day and a very big dork in real life. I have no lessons to teach. I don’t suffer from any major (alleged) illnesses beyond spotty psoriasis and allergies. I will never blog about my awful childhood. Life is pretty normal except that I waste a tremendous time on my computer creating and capturing my very boring life.

Here is me fucking around with an iGlasses for Mac upgrade on a Saturday night.

That’s right. This is about as real as it gets. I am profoundly nearsighted. (-7.75, bitches.)  Yes, that’s a white Hanes t-shirt. (I own 16 — mens size small.) I’m wearing Capri pajama pants. (Unlimited supply.) Hair is twisted back into seventeen different ponytails. (I am really Jada Pinkett Smith.)

But I know you don’t care about my real life. It’s boring to read how I accidentally charged my Paypal account twice for a single download of iGlasses. You don’t want to hear how I stepped in cat puke shortly after taking this picture. And you don’t want me to take pictures of myself in my coke bottle glasses. That’s your life.

You come here for a strong voice, a unique perspective, and a backbone. So I will always put in my contact lenses, wear a little lip gloss, and try to write something compelling for you. And I will never lie to you about my ‘crazy’ personal life. I’m cool with that arrangement if you are. I think it’s working out just fine.

Now promise me you’ll remember that the best and most interesting writers in your RSS reader aren’t crazy.

They are entertaining liars.

Some bloggers wear a mask of contact lenses and lip gloss. Some wear a mask of a crazy marriage. All of us are wearing masks, though.

As long as you approach the majority of popular blogs with a hermeneutic of suspicion, nobody ever gets hurt.

44 comments ...wanna add one?

Simon October 18, 2011 at 6:55 am

I guess that you are probably right – blogging (like being a TV commentator or shock jock) probably does need to be provocative. It’s just a pity that thoughtful, well reasoned argument gets screened out or ignored.

Reply

Laurie October 19, 2011 at 9:43 am

that’s true.

Reply

Karla Porter October 18, 2011 at 7:17 am

I could never divulge who I really am – that would be in violation of the Special Agent handbook.

Reply

Laurie October 19, 2011 at 9:44 am

we are watching you. we know who u are.

Reply

Vicki Cook October 18, 2011 at 7:33 am

I know you well enough to know that you ARE crazy, but I mean that in a good way. “Oh, you can’t help that,” said the Cat: “we’re all mad here. I’m mad. You’re mad.”

Reply

Laurie October 19, 2011 at 9:44 am

#true

Reply

Lance Haun October 18, 2011 at 8:27 am

The most popular blogs in the world aren’t the psuedo-personal type anyway. That’s my big problem with the premise. Even if changing your mental state was an option for improving your blog, it really wouldn’t help a vast majority become better.

Nobody cares about the real you because our lives are mostly boring. How you deliver interesting, relevant content is actually a real challenge, not the outcome of a mental defect (or lack thereof).

Forbes and their hacky writers win this round, though. We are the ones talking about their stupid article.

Reply

Laurie October 19, 2011 at 9:45 am

I’m pretty sure the most popular blogs are sports-related. Or something dumb like that.

I don’t mind Forbes. The article was off, though.

Reply

Wordstith October 18, 2011 at 9:01 am

I come here for the vocabulary–I’m totally going to work the phrase “hermeneutic of suspicion” into my conversations today.

Reply

Laurie October 19, 2011 at 9:45 am

lol — u r in the wrong place

Reply

Lori October 18, 2011 at 9:03 am

I am -7.75 too. LOL Omg I can has blog ;)

Reply

Laurie October 19, 2011 at 9:45 am

blind

Reply

SalesComp October 18, 2011 at 9:37 am

She references Altucher, Armstrong, & Trunk. She forgot to mention that these individual spend huge amount of time & effort on their writing & content. They have been writing this way for years. Effort & practice due to play into it.

Reply

SalesComp October 18, 2011 at 9:38 am

…do play into it. (and so does proof-reading before you hit the submit key)

Reply

Laurie October 19, 2011 at 9:46 am

The strong narrative voice is great but I’m still 100% sure that much of these bloggers are FOS.

Reply

Annie H. October 18, 2011 at 10:19 am

Hey, -6.5 L and -7.5 R. Here’s to working from home in “featherweight” Lenscrafter lenses. *high five*

Reply

Laurie October 19, 2011 at 9:46 am

awful — i cant see shit.

Reply

Cathy October 18, 2011 at 10:41 am

What I have *always* loved about you is your personal crazy.
We are all weird, and we all run around trying to find people who can share our weirdness with us. When we find people who “get” our weirdness, and their weirdness works with our weirdness, then life is good.

“As long as you approach the majority of popular blogs with a hermeneutic of suspicion, nobody ever gets hurt.” Is this a direct Chris Parr quote?

Reply

Laurie October 19, 2011 at 9:46 am

YES. He had an impact on me. ;)

Reply

Corey Feldman October 18, 2011 at 10:58 am

Everyone is crazy to someone else.

Reply

Laurie October 19, 2011 at 9:47 am

true

Reply

Jay Dolan October 18, 2011 at 11:23 am

I’m speaking about this very topic at Blogworld, and I’m so glad to read your perspective as I’m working on the presentation.

It’s amazing what people think of bloggers just because we write something down and write it with conviction. People think I’m a crazy jackass obsessed with bringing down Facebook just because I’ll swear or write about insignificant details in the user experience. But it’s all performance. The magic’s in the makeup and the stick figures.

But I’ll gladly be be known as crazy if it keeps paying the bills.

Reply

Laurie October 19, 2011 at 9:47 am

I AM SPEAKING AT BLOGWORD.

Love that fancy blogger sentence!!!!!!!

Reply

Middle Manager October 18, 2011 at 1:42 pm

I think people tend to look strange [or crazy] when only one aspect of their life or perspective is on display – as Jay pointed out above. Bloggers tend to be 2D caricatures because only a single aspect or perspective of their life [or chosen topic] is out there for the world to read.

And, as you so eloquently point out, what’s normal anyway? Normal is boring, normal is trite, normal is zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz. Crazy is fun to read and it’s fun to watch. I always love seeing the people on “reality” TV come back and say, “hey, that’s not me. They edited/scripted that. I’m not really that crazy.” Yes, yes you are. You’re crazy for not realizing they would try to make you look crazy; because crazy is far more entertaining than “normal.”

To be successful at any endeavor in which you are the product, you either have to have a really strong and fearless voice [which you do] and hippo-thick skin, or you have to be certifiable.

Reply

Laurie October 19, 2011 at 9:48 am

Those reality tv moments are priceless.

“They edited to make me look shitty.”

Riiiiiiiiight. Actually, yes. Sucker!

Reply

DK Schneider October 18, 2011 at 1:47 pm

Well, how crazy do they need to be?
1. Own a number of businesses – as if one is not enough?
2. Be the president of the HOA, on the board at church, an officer of a professional organization?
3. Write over 10,000 words a week – sometimes spiking to 25,000?
4. Do the shopping, feed the family, garden, motorcycle, draw, play with the kids?
5. Read over 30 periodicals a month and knock off a few books while at it?
Gosh, that does kind of sound rather boring.
Wearing coke-bottle-bottom glasses while wearing small men’s t-shirts and wiping cat vomit off the bottom of the fuzzy slippers sounds infinitely more exciting.

Laurie, Always a joy to read your posts.

Reply

Laurie October 19, 2011 at 9:49 am

Thanks, buddy. You are pretty crazy. That’s a good crazy.

Reply

Karen Siwak October 18, 2011 at 2:54 pm

“I’m not crazy. My mother had me tested.” Sheldon Cooper

Does that mean you aren’t really the crazy lady who owns five cats? I’m devastated.

Reply

Laurie October 19, 2011 at 9:49 am

I wish I were that woman. Would be a good goal.

Reply

Tim Sackett October 18, 2011 at 3:11 pm

I keep waiting for one of my 75 readers to actually take me seriously and figure out I’m not the sweater vest wearing, HR Pro, with an extra 20 pounds to lose (ok, 40 – assholes!), trying to be the next Kris Dunn – but alas, they just won’t believe my lying ass!

Reply

Laurie October 19, 2011 at 9:50 am

Assholes. It’s really 25 lbs.

Reply

Heather October 18, 2011 at 3:47 pm

Interesting post. In addition to a few HR blogs, I read a lot of healthy living, food and fitness blogs. I have to wonder how much of their lives do these bloggers really share b/c sometimes I find it hard to believe that they eat that many salads without ever indulging in the french fries. Lies, all lies I say!

Reply

Laurie October 19, 2011 at 9:51 am

I like fitness blogs too. Sometimes I want to comment — you know you’re anorexic, right?

Reply

Patrick Erwin October 18, 2011 at 9:30 pm

“Crazy” is just a way to oversimplify and drive traffic. You’re right – tentative voices suck. I know, because it’s something I’m working on in my writing. I have a tendency to preface everything or try to soften the blow. I respect people with a strong voice/POV. Respect doesn’t always mean agree but I’d much rather read someone with some edges and a personal story that tells me they learned this first hand than a bobblehead that can chirp out easy PR speak.

(Gah, I knew before I even clicked that link that the article would reference Penelope. Quelle surprise. Easier to label her and other writers than to look at their work.)

Reply

Laurie October 19, 2011 at 9:51 am

It’s actually offensive to me when someone calls some of these authors ‘crazy’. Im like — come on. They work hard.

Reply

Patrick Erwin October 19, 2011 at 5:32 pm

exactly. “crazy” is just an easy way to dismiss what makes us/the reader uncomfortable.

Reply

caren gittleman October 19, 2011 at 8:19 am

I “heart” this and YOU!

Reply

Laurie October 19, 2011 at 9:52 am

hey tahnks caren!

Reply

CulinaryCara October 20, 2011 at 12:25 pm

My eyeballs are a cool -4.oo, and I thought I was blind! You can see into the future with your specs!

Although I’m still a pup in the blog world, I think I’m on the right track on being a fairly successful one. There are many things I’ve learned through “on the blog” experience, but I also have an edge due to my close ties with various forms of professional media (radio/TV/film/web design/blogging/journalists/etc). Here are some of the things I learned from both:

- People don’t care about your personal life
How many times have I read blogging “How-To” articles, and that’s usually in the top 5. It’s true though, just like all that crap you just said.

- People like cheesy (recipes and writing!)
There’s a reason why news anchors have cheesy/corny one-liner teases into the next segment of news, and it rolls over quite well into blogging. My better half is a daytime news director and he occasionally picks on me for it. He knows how it works though and advises me to keep it up. He’s also been trying to get me into the professional video side of the food blog world, but that’s unfamiliar territory for me and I’m being irrationally stubborn.

- People don’t like complex language.
Which, saddens me to no end. I just read an article about one of my favorite foodie stars, Nigella Lawson, and you’ll see what I mean.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1562852/Nigella-and-Delias-recipes-not-a-piece-of-cake.html
In a nutshell, it’s proven that most of society is either too stupid, or too lazy to interpret complex language for whatever reason. It’s heart-breaking.

- People like relatable exaggerations
I suppose you can compare that notion to “white lies.” Take TV show characters, for example. Producers don’t want their characters to be completely out-there. They try to maintain traits that the viewer can relate to, but still keeping those characters a bit skewed to make the viewer vicariously believe that their own lives don’t suck.

As far as the crazy part goes, I’m always a believer of this:

To be the best at what you do, you’ve gotta be a little bit nuts :)

Reply

Pharma Giles October 20, 2011 at 4:03 pm

Utter balderdash. Every word you will read in the Pharma Giles blog is the truth. Except for the stuff I make up, of ourse. And needless to day I am the most STOP RINGING THOSE BELLS STOP RINGING THOSE BELLS normal and well-balanced chap you possibly wish to meet…

Reply

Glenda October 22, 2011 at 9:24 pm

You mean to tell me you aren’t really the crazy cat lady you portray yourself to be??? Right. It is has all been a hoax. Like Balloon Boy. Scrubby is a neighbors cat, Molly was just wondering through your yard one day and Emme, little ponchy Emma, is just a character you made up with cute little fat bags with some software program? It is all coming clear now as I have never, ever seen Jake.

Reply

David Manaster October 29, 2011 at 1:45 pm

“Sometimes wrong, but never in doubt.” The mantra of bankers and consultants.

‘Nuff said.

Reply

Laurie October 29, 2011 at 5:07 pm

That sounds like a t-shirt to me.

Reply

Leave a Comment

44 comments ...wanna add one?

Previous post:

Next post: